Four SDP witnesses appear in tribunal, give conflicting evidence

The witnesses’ gave their accounts before the three-member panel of justices, led by Justice Ado Birnin-Kudu.

The SDP and its governorship candidate, Murtala Ajaka, are challenging the victory of Gov. Usman Ododo of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in the Nov. 11, 2023 election in the state.

During the sitting on Wednesday, there were different accounts by the witnesses, especially during cross-examination, which, in most cases, could not be explained by the witnesses themselves.

A witness, Danlamin Yakubu, from Ajaokuta Local Government Area of Kogi, said that he was an agent of the SDP during the election.

Yakubu, who said he was a member of the SDP, a voter and the party’s agent during the poll, however, told the tribunal under cross-examination that he had lost everything that could prove that he was an agent.

When asked if he stated in his deposition before the tribunal that he was an agent in the election, he said that he forgot to do so.

He also alleged that his lawyer wrote his deposition for him.

When his attention was brought to paragraph 4 of his deposition that he did not indicate the total number of accredited voters, the witness said it was a typographical error.

But when the respondents’ counsel asked him to state the number he meant to write if it was a mistake, he said: “I don’t know the number.”

Although in his deposition, he indicated that the number of registered voters in his polling unit was 771, when he was asked to confirm the number, he gave a conflicting response.

“I did not indicate that I voted in my deposition,” he said.

Another witness, Abdulkareem Ogeja, from the same LGA, said though he was a member of the SDP, he did not state in his deposition his membership of the party.

He, however, said that he was not the party’s agent during the election and that the SDP had an agent at his polling unit.

When the respondent’s counsel asked if he was surprised that the SDP agent did not complain and he was the only one complaining, Ogeja said, “I’m not surprised.”

When he was asked further if he wrote the deposition by himself, he said his lawyer did it after he explained what happened to him.

When he was told to mention the name of his lawyer, the witness said: “His name is my lawyer.”

When he was asked which language he used to communicate with his lawyer, Ogeja said “in vernacular “.

The witness, who told the panel that he did not know the number of registered voters in his polling unit, also said he did not receive any paper indicating the total number on the day of election.

Contrary to Ogeja’s evidence, he was said to have quoted the figures in his deposition.

Emmanuel Ohiare, from Okehi LGA, and Abdullahi Musa from Ajaokuta LGA, equally testified at the sitting.

The tribunal adjourned the sitting until April 4 for continuation of hearing.

While the lead counsel for SDP and Ajaka was Pius Akubo, SAN; Chief Kanu Agabi, SAN, represented the Independent National Electoral Commission; Mr A.M. Aliu, SAN, appeared for Gov. Ododo and E.C. Ukala, SAN, represented the APC at the hearing.(NAN)

By Taiye Agbaje